What is HUMINT?
HUMINT is a great skill. In the Delta Green
Agent’s Handbook (page 33) the HUMINT skill is defined as, “Human intelligence. This obtains information about a subject—especially information the subject would rather conceal—through observation, conversation, or examining patterns of behavior and relationships.”
In game terms, Delta Green’s HUMINT is similar to the Psychology skill in Call of Cthulhu.
The CIA however defines HUMINT in a broader sense. In the CIA Glossary of Intelligence Terms and Definitions (1978), HUMINT is defined as “A category of intelligence information derived from human sources,” (page 7).
That definition is vague. We will be using the definition from the excellent dissertation of Kevin Quinlan (Cambridge, 2005) that is titled “Human Intelligence Tradecraft and MI5 Operations in Britain, 1919-1940.” In the introduction of Quinlan’s thesis, HUMINT is referred to as the recruitment and handling of agents and informants, and the tradecraft skills behind those activities.
Delta Green Agents, or player characters, can use examples of Human Intelligence tradecraft from real world intelligence history to counter human based Mythos threats in a Delta Green game. Specifically, if the Mythos threat is a human cult.
I will be using references and historical examples from Quinlan’s thesis to give ideas for actions DG agents can take in game to interdict Mythos cults, and suggest some DG scenarios inspired by historical actions taken by MI5 during the interwar period (1919-1940).
TL;DR: I read a thesis on a bunch of MI5 spy stories and see if I can extract any gameable gems for Delta Green games.
Are there real-life examples of intelligence agencies’ tradecraft that a DG GM could use in games?
Yes. In Quinlan’s thesis the point is made that studying the interwar (between WW1 and WW2) period of MI5’s (the UK’s domestic counter-intelligence and security agency) actions against communist espionage and subversion, mirrors the modern (as of 2008) struggle against Islamist terrorism; because they deal with the same question: “how does a security service confront an ideologically driven enemy who operates in secretive cells, who blends in with the local population, and who is determined to destroy the status quo, if necessary (and often if possible) through violent means?”
Mythos cults are an ideologically driven enemy who operate in the same manner as described above.
I suggest, that in studying the tradecraft MI5 used against interwar communist groups, DG GMs can run a more nuanced and interesting HUMINT campaign against Mythos cults, either written in published scenarios or homebrewed. For example, I think this information could be useful in playing DG agents in the scenarios
Iconoclasts or
Ladybug, Ladybug. Though the latter is technically a Call of Cthulhu adventure published by Stygian Fox; it is often run by DG groups.
Quinlan writes, “As long as governments have secrets, other intelligence agencies will seek to steal them. Case officers attempt to acquire these secrets by recruiting sources with access to secrets. This is typically accomplished by exploiting the desires, weaknesses, and ideologies of those who are privy to the secrets. Just as money, ideology, compromise, and ego ('MICE') were leveraged against agents in the interwar period, so they were equally leveraged against agents in the Cold War. History suggests that discovering 'entry points' and apprehending a potential agent's wants require patience, attention to individual psychology and motivation, and an understanding of the overall operational context,” (page 327).
I think these three points I bolded above are operationally valuable for DG characters and players.
Regarding the first point, surveillance and human interaction with the a "mark" in a Mythos cult should attempt to identify the individuals in the cult who are least dangerous and who have the most access to secrets. In some cases, the operational objective for the DG agent is to determine which cultist(s) has access to hypergeometric powers (i.e. are wizards) and work around those very dangerous individuals.
Point two suggests that analysis of the "mark"'s psychology and motivation should be exploited in the MICE framework to turn the "mark" into an intelligence asset or possible saboteur. In
The Call of Cthulhu Inspector Legrasse's debrief of Old Castro is an interrogation, but not exactly one where the mark Old Castro is turned into an intelligence asset. This is despite the fact that Old Castro gives the Inspector information about the Old Ones. My read on this is that Old Castro is simply faintly amused by telling the Inspector that all his society and authority is fucking irrelevant in the face of Great Cthulhu and terrible cosmic forces.
I'd call Old Castro a hardcase and true believer. Not a cultist that folded under police interrogation and became an informant.
But not all cultists will be that hardcore. Some will just be useful hands for the cult. Others insane. Some both. Take the example of
The Dunwich Horror and Lavinia Whateley in that story. Victim, insane, and "strangely proud of the dark, goatish-looking infant " she bore; Lavinia none less could possibly be flipped as an asset if successfully handled by an operative using MICE to act against the Whateley family cult.
Point three suggests the DG agent use HUMINT or SIGINT skills to surveil the cultist “mark”, assess their psychological frailties, and eventually arrange a meeting with the “mark” or attempt to flip the “mark” through some sort of remote means. Now I’ll be honest. This leaves a lot of heavy lifting to the Delta Green GM. The DG GM has to come up with a fleshed-out NPC with internal wants, needs, and vulnerabilities the players can figure out and then use as hooks to get them to do what the players want. Probably more than one NPC needs to be developed in this manner. Having said that, stealing from historical or fictional spy stories for characters could be a short cut for a clever GM short on time.
Quinlan also writes that tradecraft boils down to “methods of communication, meeting arrangements, source protection, and agent-handling.” These techniques should be kept in mind by the DG intelligence agent during play.
Particularly source protection.
After all, you don’t want to waste all the valuable time and resources of the conspiracy.
Do you?
Special thanks to Anonymous.
No comments:
Post a Comment